During oral arguments, students present their cases before a panel of judges, typically consisting of two students, one faculty member, and one practicing attorney or judge.
Wednesday, March 6, 2024

Congratulations to the Iowa Law students who showcased their skills in the final competitions of the Appellate Advocacy Program! 

The Appellate Advocacy Program (AAII) offers second-year students a platform to hone their advocacy skills by preparing and presenting arguments on legal issues in a simulated adversarial environment. During oral arguments, students present their cases before a panel of judges, typically consisting of two students, one faculty member, and one practicing attorney or judge. 

The culminating events for this year’s Appellate Advocacy Program occurred on March 1, featuring two distinct competitions: the Jessup and Van Oosterhout-Baskerville (VOB). Siduri Beckman secured the top advocate award in the VOB competition, while Michael Acherkan claimed the title of best advocate in the Jessup competition. 

Michael Acherkan reflects on his rewarding experience in AAII, emphasizing the invaluable teamwork and support from his partners throughout the competition. 

“I had a great experience in AAII, and the teamwork aspect was awesome. I'm grateful for all the hard work my partner Isaac put in during the first round. I would have struggled a lot when it came time to switch issues if not for him. And Patty, my partner for the final round, was the best teammate anyone could have asked for. To me, that's the best part of Appellate Advocacy, teamwork that involves supporting your partner and trusting them to support you in the same way. It's extremely rewarding, and I recommend AAII to anyone looking to become a better advocate while in law school.” 

3L and executive director of AAII, Michael Hegarty, expresses immense pride in this year's award winners and incoming national competition teams. 

“The Board and I are so proud of this year’s award winners and the incoming national competition teams. Their achievements are the direct result of two semesters of hard work, not a second of which is lost on us. We cannot wait to follow their triumphs during Supreme Court Day, each of their national competitions, and the rest of their careers.” 

Isabelle Breitfelder, a 3L serving as the academic director of AAII, echoes Hegarty’s enthusiasm for seeing her peers excel. 

“I am incredibly excited for the final round advocates and those who will compete on the moot court teams next year,” says Isabelle. “As I was helping the final round advocates prepare and watching the final rounds, I realized how grateful I am for my time with the moot court programs and how fortunate those advocates are to have another year of moot court. I’m sure going to miss it!” 

Iowa Supreme Court Day, the college’s longest-standing tradition, marks an annual celebration honoring the state’s highest court and commemorating National Constitution Day. The top 2L advocates from this spring’s VOB and Jessup competitions will have the opportunity to argue a moot case before the justices in the fall as they transition to 3Ls. Public oral arguments will also take place during the event. 

Having observed her peers argue before the Supreme Court Justices during her 1L year, Siduri Beckman was captivated by the opportunity. Now, that fascination has materialized into an exciting reality as she and her peers Sydney Wagner, Alex Lewis, and Matthew Moreland were chosen to present their case at this year’s Supreme Court Day on Friday, September 6, 2024. 

“Watching Iowa Supreme Court Day was one of the first things that I did as a 1L, and I immediately became excited about the opportunity to argue in front of real judges as a law student,” says Siduri. “I was thrilled to be chosen to participate in the final round of the VOB Competition, although I’ll admit that I was nervous before the argument started. However, once I started answering questions from judges who knew every nuance of that area of law, I felt the same excitement all over again. I’m honored to have had the opportunity to argue in front of Judge Kelly, Judge Locher, Magistrate Judge Docherty, and Judge Bailey, and I’m very grateful to my mentors at Iowa Law.” 

As we wrap up this year’s VOB and Jessup competitions, Iowa Law extends its heartfelt appreciation to the members of the AAII Board for their exceptional efforts throughout the year. 

2023 - 2024 Board members include: 

  • Michael Hegarty, Executive Director

  • Isabelle Breitfelder, Academic Director 

  • Hugh Zehr, Administrative Director 

  • Cari Wadman, Supreme Court Day Coordinator and Competitions Director 

  • Jake Elliott, Appellate Advocacy I Problem Writer 

  • Jaycie Owens, Van Oosterhout-Baskerville Problem Writer 

  • Jessica Davis, Jessup Problem Writer 

Below, you’ll find comprehensive results from both the VOB and Jessup competitions, details about the advocates for Supreme Court Day, and a preview of next year’s Moot Court competition teams. 

Van Oosterhout-Baskerville (VOB) Competition 

VOB Top Advocate: 

  • Siduri Beckman  

VOB Top Three Oralists: 

  • Alex Lewis  

  • Matthew Moreland  

  • Elliott Abromeit 

VOB Top Three Briefs: 

  • Kyle Glanzer  

  • Sydney Wagner  

  • Matthew Moreland  

Jessup Competition 

  • Jessup Top Advocate: Mikhail Acherkan 

  • Jessup Top Three Oralists: 

  • Johnathan Melvin  

  • West Connors  

  • Cami Hunter 

  • Jessup Top Three Briefs: 

  • Ashley Chipokas  

  • Patricia Linninger  

  • Johnathan Melvin   

Supreme Court Day Advocates 

  • Siduri Beckman

  • Sydney Wagner

  • Alex Lewis

  • Matthew Moreland  

Moot Court Competition Teams (2024-2025) 

National Moot Court Team: 

  • Siduri Beckman  

  • Alec Goos  

  • Lydia Lavrova  

  • Alex Lewis  

  • Matthew Moreland  

  • Sydney Wagner  

Baskerville Team: 

  • Garrison Allen  

  • Allie (Alethea) Gauthier  

  • Andrew Hamilton  

  • Amy Johnson  

  • James Miller  

  • Brennden Prohaska  

Environmental Moot Team: 

  • Alex LeLouis 

  • Jonathan Lewallen  

  • Zachary Sides  

Jessup Team: 

  • Catriona Barr  

  • Chandler Farquhar  

  • Patricia Linninger 

  • Johnathan Melvin  

  • Kevin Moore